Here at the frontier, the leaves fall like rain. Although my neighbors are all barbarians, and you, you are a thousand miles away, there are still two cups at my table.


Ten thousand flowers in spring, the moon in autumn, a cool breeze in summer, snow in winter. If your mind isn't clouded by unnecessary things, this is the best season of your life.

~ Wu-men ~


Saturday, November 21, 2026

The Long Defeat




The Long Defeat

Nearly everyone I know has watched the Lord of the Rings films. Many have read Tolkien's original books. Some have ventured further into the history of Middle-earth through The Silmarillion. It is an extraordinary body of work, spanning thousands of years, populated by gods, heroes, kings, and creatures both wondrous and terrible.

Much of the weight of that history is carried by the Elves.

They are among the oldest inhabitants of Middle-earth. They have witnessed the rise and fall of kingdoms, fought great wars, and stood against forces of darkness that threatened the very existence of the world they knew. They have known extraordinary victories and suffered devastating defeats.

Yet beneath all of this is a theme that is rather different from the familiar story of good triumphing over evil.

Tolkien called it the long defeat.

The struggle against darkness is never finally won. Evil may be defeated, but at a cost, and it returns in another form, in another age. Kingdoms rise and fall. Great works are created and eventually lost. Even the most consequential victories cannot arrest the passage of time or prevent the eventual diminishment of the things they valued.

They are immortal, at least in the sense that they do not succumb to the ordinary aging and death of Men. They can be killed, but otherwise they endure. And yet their immortality does not protect them from loss. They watch the world they love change around them. The kingdoms and places they have known diminish. The things they have created pass away. The world increasingly belongs to others. Their future is not one of eternal triumph or even continued prominence. It is one of fading. Eventually, they will become shadows in a world that has moved on, remembered only in stories and fairy tales.

The Elves cannot preserve the world in which they are immortal.

Yet they continued to make, preserve, defend, and love things.

And when the time came, many of them departed. They didn't mistake departure for failure, nor did they pretend that Middle-earth could remain what it had been. Those who stayed faded slowly, and that fading was part of the story too.

I find myself thinking about this in connection with several aesthetic sensibilities — ways of seeing and living in a world in which nothing remains quite as it was. They build on one another, each one deepening the last.

It begins with the recognition of impermanence. Everything changes. Nothing is exempt from the passage of time. This is not necessarily a cause for despair; it is simply a fundamental condition of existence. We picture it in the glorious colors of autumn fading into winter. Given their immortality, the Elves would have watched rivers change course and forests spring up and disappear. I can't help but feel they would have felt impermanence, and the passing of time, that much more deeply. What we find fixed and immutable, they would find fleeting.

Recognition deepens into poignancy. A blossom is beautiful, but part of its beauty lies in knowing that it will soon fall. Its brevity does not diminish the experience. In some respects, it makes us more attentive to it.

There is beauty in imperfection, age, and the marks left by time. A weathered object may possess a character that it never had when new. The cracks, worn surfaces, and imperfections are not necessarily defects to be corrected. They are evidence of a life lived.

Finally, there is the ongoing cultivation and refinement of oneself — a continuing process of becoming, rather than the pursuit of a final state of perfection. Perhaps this is especially important when the familiar measures of achievement and accomplishment begin to lose their relevance.

I am growing older. I am engaged in my own long defeat.

Unlike the Elves, I am mortal. I don't have the luxury of watching centuries pass, knowing that I will endure. My losses are more immediate and, in some respects, more personal.

I have limits, and they are shrinking. I don't yet know their extent. I must find out. I notice changes in what I can do, in what comes easily and what now requires effort. There are things I once took for granted that I can no longer assume. Some possibilities have narrowed. Some doors have closed.

Aging is not merely something happening to the body. It is an invitation to discover what is happening to the person inhabiting it.

There is also the gradual relinquishment of identity.

For much of my life, I have understood myself through the things I did, the skills I developed, the challenges I accepted, and the accomplishments I accumulated. They have shaped how I see myself and how I engage with the world.

Around me I see men who have identified with their work their whole lives, and in retirement face the difficult work of finding a new identity.

Who am I when I can no longer do everything I once could? Perhaps the question isn't how much longer we can do the things we've always done. It's what remains possible, what new possibilities emerge, and how fully we can participate in the life still available to us.

Participation doesn't require the ability to prevail. It requires the willingness to remain engaged for as long as engagement is possible.

I don't think the answer is to abandon the things that have given my life meaning. Nor do I think it is useful to cling to an earlier version of myself, measuring every present experience against what I could once accomplish. Self cultivation need not end when the possibility of achievement diminishes; the process itself can become the point. There is still value in learning, practicing, refining, and attending to the life one has.

Perhaps the answer is to continue cultivating oneself while becoming less attached to the identity that has accumulated along the way.

This is about acceptance, not surrender. It means recognizing the conditions under which we must live and finding ways to live fully within them.

The Elves are immortal, but their world is not. We are mortal, and the world we inhabit continues beyond us.

But there is a difference between recognizing that something will pass and deciding that it therefore has diminished value. A season does not become less beautiful because it ends. A relationship does not become less meaningful because it cannot last forever. A life does not become less valuable because its capacities and possibilities change with age.

I don't imagine that I will ever entirely reconcile myself to the losses that accompany aging. Nor do I think that is necessary. There is room for regret, sadness, and even resistance. Acceptance need not be an uninterrupted state of serenity.

But I can recognize that the passage of time is not simply something happening to me. It is the condition in which I continue to live.

The long defeat is not an argument for giving up. It is an invitation to reconsider what constitutes a meaningful victory. Perhaps it is enough to continue showing up, to remain curious, to cultivate what can still be cultivated, and to find beauty in things that are imperfect, temporary, and inevitably changing.

It is about learning to recognize beauty in a world that cannot be held still, and learning to inhabit that world while it is still ours. 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Musha Shuugyou: The Warrior's Pilgrimage


There was recently an interesting article at The Okinawan Empty Hand blog, about Musha Shuugyou, the warrior's pilgrimage. Below is an excerpt. The full post may be read here.

 Understanding Musha Shugyo (武者修行)

Cold rain on the road
Each footfall reveals the ground
Dawn finds no master


Wooden swords fall still
The guest bows before the gate
Wind carries no rank


What the journey means

Musha-shugyō is the Japanese practice commonly described as a warrior’s training pilgrimage: leaving familiar surroundings to deepen martial understanding through travel, encounters, study, and testing. Its historical forms varied. For a modern martial artist, its most useful lesson is that skill needs examination beyond the conditions in which it became comfortable. That lesson does not require imitating the hazards or social assumptions of earlier Japan. [1, 2]


Musha means warrior. Shugyō refers to disciplined training or cultivation, often carrying a stronger sense of sustained personal effort than an ordinary practice session. The term is written in forms including 武者修行 and 武者修業. 


In English, musha shugyo, musha-shugyō, and musha shugyō are common renderings; the macron marks the long final vowel. “Warrior pilgrimage” captures the journey, although “martial training journey” can sound less religious to modern ears. [1, 2]


Think of a practitioner who understands timing against familiar partners. At another school, the distance changes, the rhythm changes, and the familiar response arrives too late. The encounter exposes a gap. What happens afterward—careful study, correction, and further testing—determines whether the visit becomes education or merely an uncomfortable afternoon. This example is a modern illustration, rather than a reconstruction of a particular historical event.


More than a search for opponents

A scholarly overview by Marcos Sala Ivars places martial travel alongside religious and artistic interests connected with Japanese sword culture. That broader setting matters: the historical journey cannot be reduced to a succession of fights. Nor should every story of wandering, hardship, or sudden enlightenment be treated as a reliable account of how warriors generally trained. [2]


The distinction throughout this article is between documented historical examples, later interpretations, and present-day proposals. A useful modern idea can draw inspiration from the past without claiming to reproduce it exactly.


History beyond the wandering swordsman

Aikido Journal’s brief encyclopedia entry associates musha-shugyō especially with the Edo period, when martial artists traveled between training halls to test and improve their abilities. Japan’s Edo period is conventionally dated 1603–1868. This is an important context, but it does not establish a single founder, universal curriculum, or uninterrupted ritual followed by every warrior. The label describes a practice with variation, rather than one standardized institution. [1, 2]


The familiar picture of a lone swordsman walking into danger is only part of the story. Muta Bunnosuke, a swordsman from Saga, undertook a journey in 1853–1855 and left a detailed diary. Asahi’s description of Yoshio Nagai’s study reports that Muta traveled with domain permission, trained at welcoming schools, socialized with local warriors, and visited sights and hot springs. Inns serving traveling practitioners could help arrange introductions to training halls. [3]


That evidence changes the emphasis. Some martial travel involved support, networks, and organized access. Hospitality and serious training could coexist. The National Diet Library catalogs Nagai’s revised 2023 volume and identifies its relationship to the 2013 study. The diary is valuable precisely because its ordinary details resist the assumption that authentic training always required isolation and misery. This article uses the publisher’s description and catalog record, rather than claiming a direct reading of the complete diary. [3, 4]


Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Shinei Taido of Noriake Inoue


Noriake Inoue was the nephew of the founder of Aikido, Morihei Ueshiba. He was with his during the development of the latter's Aiki Budo and early aikido. He was roughly a contemporary of Kenji Tomiki. 

Around about 1935, due to differences between the two men, Inoue left and developed his own version of the martial art which he called Shinwa Taido, and later renamed to Shinei Taido. 

Below is a video of Inoue.


Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Aikido and Competition


With the exception of Tomiki Aikido, competition is largely absent from the practice of Aikido. what is that? 

At Aikido Sangenkai, there is a fascinating article about this and this history of aikido. An excerpt is below. The full post may be read here.

Kenji Tomiki, Morihei Ueshiba’s first 8th Dan in Aikido, often referred to the famous famous rising dragon story when discussing competitive practice:

Randori practice, sparring practice, is something that is done to give life to, and demonstrate the real power of, those techniques that were first learned by the student through kata. That is to say, randori provides the means to complete a painted dragon by filling in the eyes.

The reference here, if you’re unfamiliar with the story, is to the story of the famous Chinese artist Zhang Sengyou, who painted four dragons on the walls of Anle Temple in what is now Nanjing around the year 500.

He painted the dragons completely except for the eyes, believing that the paintings were so realistic that if he drew the eyes, they would come alive and fly away.

Responding to people’s disbelief at this assertion, Zhang then painted the eyes of two of the dragons, and they immediately flew away to heaven riding on clouds and thunder. This became the famous proverb, “to paint a dragon and dot in the eyes” – 画竜点睛 (“Garyou Tensei”, in Japanese).

Of course, this represents one of Kenji Tomiki’s motivations in creating a competitive form in Aikido – to bring life to techniques trained in the classical Kata format (which he did not abandon) by applying them in under live resistance.

The second of Kenji Tomiki’s motivations was that he believed that competition could be a unifying force in the Aikido community, providing a standardized technical framework under which all Aikido students could meet and train, even if they normally employed different training methodologies at home, a commonly agreed upon neutral ground upon which Aikido students from many different traditions would be able to meet and train together.

He was not alone in conceiving of a useful place for some form of competition in the training pedagogy.

Minoru Mochizuki, for example, whom Morihei Ueshiba asked twice, one before and once after the war, to take over his art, instituted sparring and competition in Yoseikan Aikido.

In another example, Koichi Tohei, Morihei Ueshiba’s only 10th Dan to be promoted through official Aikikai channels, created a form of competition more like “figure skating” with annual Taigi Competitions.

It’s worth noting that this type of competition is also frowned upon by the Aikikai, and has been the cause of some controversy in the past:

The IAF holds a general congress every four years and the official reason for holding it in Japan is to allow the instructors residing overseas to visit Japan and recharge their cultural batteries, so to speak. An exception was made in 1992, however, when the Congress was held in Taipei. I was IAF General Secretary and it was my responsibility to organize this vast meeting with Paul C N Lee, who was President of the Republic of China Aikido Association (ROCAA). At IAF Congresses it is customary to have aikido training seminars and to hold a demonstration in which representatives from all the member nations participate. The arrangements for the aikido seminars and the demonstration were the responsibility of the host country, in this case the ROCAA. During one meeting at the Hombu, attended by Mr Lee, Fujita Sensei and myself, Kisshomaru Doshu had appeared and urged us all to exercise great caution, but to me his warning was about as obscure as Dumbledore’s warnings to Harry Potter. Fujita Sensei was a close friend of Mr Lee and fully understood the very difficult conditions under which the ROCAA was operating, but I had no idea of these conditions and was unprepared for the explosion that was about to occur.

After the arrangements for the Congress had been publicized, certain Japanese overseas instructors sent fax messages to the Aikikai requesting the dismissal of two officials, on the grounds that they were responsible for organizing competitions in aikido, at a congress that was about to take place. One official was Fujita Sensei, who was the Hombu Dojo Secretary; the other was myself, the IAF Secretary. These fax messages were received by Fujita Sensei in the Hombu office, who promptly sent copies on to me.

The Congress took place and the atmosphere can best be described as taut. The wa, so important at international aikido meetings was certainly there, but underlying this was a tension that sometimes appeared at meetings as straight conflict. I was in a very difficult position, however, for I had discovered independently that the condition imposed by the local Olympic committee in Taiwan for the operation of aikido by the ROCAA was that they had to hold aikido demonstrations that could be seen to outsiders as competitions, with judges holding up scorecards after each demonstration. The Aikikai had known about this condition for several years, but had remained silent and it was only now, with an impending demonstration that would be attended by officials of the local Olympic committee, that it had become an issue. I happened to have lunch with Doshu one day and warned him that I had no intention of resigning and that I would have to explain to the entire Congress that the Aikikai had known all along about ‘competition’ aikido in Taiwan and had done nothing about it. This lack of action would certainly be construed as approval and would cause a conflict that might have the same consequiences as Tohei Sensei’s departure from the Aikikai. Doshu pursed his lips and answered that he did not want any explosion at the Congress (the problem of wa arising again), but he added that ‘Fujita does not understand international matters.’

Both Fujita Sensei and the present Doshu, who was Hombu Dojo-cho at the time, gave up their positions in the Hombu to ‘take responsibility.’ I had also been pressed to do this by the instructors who desired my dismissal, but I refused: I was not a Japanese and did not intend to be treated like one in this instance.

“It Had To Be Felt #50: Masatake Fujita: When is a Hombu Deshi Not a Deshi? When He’s the Secretary“, by Peter Goldsbury

Be that as it may, Kisshomaru Ueshiba made the choice after the war to strictly prohibit any form of competitive practice within the Aikikai (eventually, but that will become clear later on).

Note that I say Kisshomaru Ueshiba, and not Morihei Ueshiba.

It is quite common to hear assertions that any form of competition was prohibited as a kind of “heresy” by the Founder himself, Morihei Ueshiba, and that the “heretic” (namely, Kenji Tomiki) was cast into the outer darkness, but that’s not really the entire story.

Ueshiba did not, apparently, see himself as betraying Deguchi by striking out on his own path (nor did Deguchi, from all statements we have), nor was Ueshiba, apparently, overly concerned with his students who went theirs. Shioda Gozo described visiting Ueshiba four days before his death. Ueshiba awoke and said, “It’s you, thanks for coming. I’m riding on a winged horse around the heavens. I can see the earth. Shioda, what is [Kenji] Tomiki doing now? I’m watching.” Of all the people to ask for on his deathbed! Many, including Ueshiba Kisshomaru, considered Tomiki to be the ultimate apostate— aikidō’s first 8th dan, a modern, practical, and educated man, who tried to meld aikidō and jūdō, and even ‘worse,’ established a competitive form of aikidō. In many people’s fantasy, Tomiki would be the last person that Ueshiba would want to see. But as far as Ueshiba was concerned, Tomiki, as much as anyone he taught, lived out his mission in this world—and that is all he was required to do. Tomiki’s students, too, despite their separation from Kisshomaru’s organization, were still practicing aikidō, still contributing their energy to Ueshiba. All, therefore, was well.

“Hidden in Plain Sight: Esoteric Power Training Within Japanese Martial Traditions; Tracing the Roots of Ueshiba Morihei’s Power“, by Ellis Amdur

Just as discussed above by Ellis Amdur, Morihei Ueshiba was rarely concerned with the direction that his students chose to go in their training, leaving them free to make their own choices.

In fact, he specifically refrained from establishing the kind of authoritative structure that would have supported that type of regulation over his students, stating that “there is no Soke in Budo”.

Morihei Ueshiba himself established no clear succession for his passing, once again leaving things to his students to figure out on their own.

After Morihei Ueshiba’s passing Kisshomaru’s authority and title were the result of negotiations among the remaining parties, which would lead to some difficulties – such as Koichi Tohei’s “declaration of independence” in Hawai’i recounted by Ralph Glanstein.

It was only after his father’s passing that Kisshomaru Ueshiba began to implement a kind of “iemoto” (家元) system within the Aikikai – an organization based around a family authority.

It is, however, quite common to see people appeal to authority in order to justify their own assertions.

I started presenting my koshinage in the All Japan aikido taikai. Arikawa-sensei told me to stop. He said it wasn’t aikido. I told him that until Osensei told me to stop, I’d keep doing it.

In Memory of Kuroiwa Yoshio – 黒岩洋志郎 — 1932- 2010

Morihei Ueshiba never told Yoshio Kuroiwa to stop.

He never told Kenji Tomiki to stop, either.

Morihei Ueshiba himself retired in 1942 , stating in his own words that he “left it all to Kisshomaru”, and remaining essentially a figure head where organizational matters were concerned. Actions and negotiations between Kenji Tomiki and the Aikikai were conducted and managed by Kisshomaru Ueshiba, not Morihei, as we will see below.

Additionally, the first competitions in Kenji Tomiki’s Aikido didn’t actually occur until the 1st All Japan University Student Aikido Competition on November 11th 1970 – more than a year after Morihei Ueshiba’s passing.

Morihei Ueshiba himself was opposed to competition, in general, but this was quite normal in his time.

His contemporary, Jigoro Kano, expressed reservations about competition in Judo.

Another contemporary, Gichin Funakoshi, opposed all competition in Karate.

Today those are both Olympic sports.

Competition in Kendo was still a relatively new idea, gaining popularity with Sakakibara Kenkichi – recently enough that he was said to be one of Sokaku Takeda’s own instructors.

Morihei Ueshiba himself practiced an art that already had no competition – Daito-ryu Aiki-jujutsu, and that art is still without competition to this day.

More importantly, Morihei Ueshiba himself rarely discussed competition at all, it wasn’t really on his radar, wasn’t an issue of major concern. On the rare occasions when he did discuss it, his objections were largely technical, the same types of issues discussed by Jigoro Kano and Gichin Funakoshi, rather than the ethical or moral issues often cited today by Aikido students.

Morihei Ueshiba spent much, much more time discussing other matters, at great length, most of which are largely ignored today.

This is important because the official statements by the Aikikai often cite phrases such as “immutable principles of the Founder”, leading us to ask what those principles would actually consist of, and if they’re “immutable” then how some (such as competition) can be cherry picked while others are ignored.

For example, Morihei Ueshiba’s statement in 1960 of the first (and presumably most important) principle defining Aikido – a right wing ultra-nationalistic form of Emperor worship, is not (we would hope)very popular today.

What actually happened, however, was less a matter of principles, immutable or otherwise, than it was a matter of the branding and marketing of Aikido in the post-war Aikikai by Kisshomaru Ueshiba.

The branding of Aikikai Aikido was initially spurred on by pressure from the rise of the Yoshinkan.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Cheng Man Ching 37 Taijiquan Form Circa 1946 Photos

 


A good find. 

This is an AI enhanced video of photos used by Cheng Man Ching promoting his "simplified" 37 form in a newspaper. 



 

Wednesday, October 28, 2026