Below is an excerpt from an interesting post at Brooklyn Monk in Asia about a wrestler, who studies Shuai Jaio while he is in China, comparing and contrasting Judo; which is research he is conducting for a PhD. The full post may be read here. I am looking forward to reading the whole series.
Sensei Gary Rasanen, an 8th degree grand master of judo grabs my
sleeve and my lapel, similar to a grip used in Chinese shuai jiao
wrestling. He pulls me into his hip, sits down slightly, while pulling
my arm across his chest, and suddenly, I am airborne. I slam, hard on
the mat, as his body crashes down on top of me. Careful to maintain
control of my arm, he rotates his hip toward me and widens his legs, in
order to drop more weight on my chest, making it hard for me to breath.
Maintaining his balance, and careful to keep his weight on me, his legs
walk around my head. As he goes, I am slowly being choked with my own
arm. Because of my MMA training, I can survive the oxygen deprivation
without taping. But this is judo. Sensei Gary only needs to hold me in
this position for twenty-five seconds. Then he will be declared the
winner of the bout.
And this was my introduction to judo.
But why was I here, lying on the mat in Port Jefferson Station, at
Long Island Judo & Martial Arts, with an eighth degree master
choking me? The answer is, it was part of my school homework.
My PhD dissertation research, at Shanghai University of Sport, where I
live and train, is a comparison between Chinese traditional shuai jiao
wrestling and modern freestyle wrestling. Additionally, I also study san
da, as many of the san da throws come directly from Chinese shuai jiao.
Because of obvious similarities between judo and shuai jiao, I am
interested in more deeply studying the art of judo. Hopefully, I will
continue with this series, as I come to know more about judo.
Grand Master Gary Rasanen started training in 1968, at age 11, in New
York’s oldest dojo, in Brooklyn. He once trained with the Korean
Olympic team and is versed in jujitsu and shotokan karate. “It was all
part of the budokan system of martial arts.” Explained Sensei Gary. “To
be proficient in that style, you have to be versed in those three arts.”
Keeping with this spirit of being an all-around fighter, sensei Gary’s
judo school is located inside of United Studios, Progressive Martial
Arts center where students were learning a variety of martial arts under
the direction of Renshi Enzo Aliotta.
The reason I sought out a judo master, during one of my brief trips
to the United States, was because the Chinese claim that judo and
Chinese shuai jiao share a common origin. Not only did I not care if
that was true, but as a doctoral candidate at a Chinese university, I
wanted to steer as clear of that sensitive issue as I could. As both, a
martial artist, and a guy from Brooklyn, however, it was obvious to see
that there were some clear similarities between the arts. First off, we
both wore heavy white jackets and belts around our waist, which could be
used for gripping, controlling and throwing.
As an MMA fighter I had been exposed to Brazilian Jujitsu and was always
fascinated to research the Japanese origins of that art. As jujitsu and
judo are related, I was also very curious to find out about the ground
fighting aspects of judo. If you ask the average person on the streets,
they have most likely heard of judo. But if you asked them what it was,
they would most likely say something about takedowns and throws, rather
than joint locks and submissions.
“Judo has grappling, submissions, choking, arm-bars, joint
manipulations… There’s a lot more to it than throwing someone to the
ground.” Explained Sensei Gary. “A few years ago, 70% of fights were won
on the ground.” I was wondering how it worked that some fights were won
by throwing and some by submission. “If I take you down in half throw,
wazari, I have to hold you on the ground for 25 seconds to get the win.”
Apparently, a Wazari is a half a point throw, which differs from an
Ippon, which is a full throw, which ends a match. To end a judo match
with a throw, the opponent must land flat on his back. If not, you have
to go to the ground and control him for 25 seconds. Or, after the
wazari, the match can end on the ground, by choke or submission, like in
jujitsu or MMA.
In MMA and in freestyle wrestling, you are generally just looking for
a win, by any legal means. But when you start practicing a specific
art, such as judo or shuai jiao, the question always arises “Do you just
want to win? Or do you want to use the art?” For example, my shuai jiao
team at the university is complete made up of former Greco Roman
competitor, except me, I come from an MMA background. If we wrestle just
for the win or just or the takedown, I would generally put my money on
my teammates vs. nearly any club team in Shanghai. But, having said
that, this year, 2014, my team pulled out of the national shuai jiao
championships, because they were afraid they would be disqualified or
penalized for not using proper shuai jiao techniques.
I asked Sensei Gary if there was some similar situation in judo. He
explained, “There are three types of judo instructors: technically
sound, but no competition, or someone who loves competition, but whose
techniques are not on par with a technically sound black belt, or others
who can teach you to compete on Olympic level.”
No comments:
Post a Comment